How to Turn Plan Your Visit Sign-ups into Sunday Guests: Calls, Texts, and Voicemail Scripts

Quick answer

If people are filling out your "Plan Your Visit" form but not showing up on Sunday, the missing link is almost always a quick, personal conversation between the moment they sign up and Sunday morning.

Should you call or text? Both, in that order: a quick text, then a call. A text from a real person lets them know who's about to call, and a phone call is where the friendship actually starts. Reach out within 15 minutes, leave a specific voicemail if they don't pick up, call back 5 minutes later, and always end your texts with a question.

This guide is written for the person on your team making those calls and texts. Hand it to them, and they'll know exactly what to say. 🙌

Watch the training: we walk through this whole playbook live at a Church Fuel Pastors Gathering.

Before you start: know your goal

The goal of following up isn't to get someone to show up one time. It's to help them make a friend. If a guest makes one real friend in their first few weeks, almost everything else takes care of itself. Your call might be the first step in that friendship.

  • Pray first. Before you call or text, pray for that person by name. Ask God to begin working in their life and help them get plugged into His church. It changes the way you show up.
  • A sign-up is not a guest yet. Treat Plan Your Visit sign-ups as interested contacts. They become a confirmed visit once they tell you, by phone or text, that they're coming. That's what your conversation is for.
  • Put the right person on the front lines. Ideally, have a female team member or volunteer lead the outreach. Look for someone whose gift is hospitality or encouragement, often a middle-aged woman who "never meets a stranger." A direct call from a male senior pastor can feel intimidating to a guest, and a warm, friendly voice lowers the barrier.

Bonus: put your point person in your ads

If you have a highly relational hospitality or connections person making these calls, don't hide her behind the scenes. Put her face in your invite ads too. Have her record a short, warm video like this:

"Hi, I'm Susie! I lead our hospitality team here at Grace Church, and honestly, my favorite part of every week is meeting people who are visiting for the very first time. So here's my personal promise to you: when you tap that button and plan your visit, I'm the one who's going to reach out. Not a robot, not a form letter. Me. I'll answer your questions, save you a great parking spot, show you exactly where to check in your kids, and make sure someone's looking for you at the door on Sunday. You'll walk in feeling like you've already got a friend here, because you will. So go ahead and plan your visit. I can't wait to meet you!"

Why this is a game changer: the person in the ad is the person who calls them is the person who greets them on Sunday. When Susie's name pops up on their phone, she's not a stranger. She's the friendly face they already met in the ad, and that makes them much more likely to answer and walk through your doors.

Part 1: When someone plans a visit

Step 1: Reach out within 15 minutes

Interest is highest the moment someone hits submit. Waiting a day or two quietly tells a guest they aren't important. Aim for 5 to 15 minutes from the notification.

What about late-night sign-ups? Someone filling out a church form at 1 a.m. is often carrying something heavy. If you have a volunteer who works overnight or is a night owl, a fast reply will stand out and show incredible care. If not, it's okay to reach out first thing the next morning. Use wisdom and pray about it.

Step 2: Send a quick text first

Phones screen unknown numbers, so a text that introduces you makes your call much more likely to get answered. Start with your name and your church. That pattern helps their phone offer to save you as a contact instead of flagging you as spam.

Text 1: "Hey [First Name], this is [Your Name] from [Church Name]. Saw you planned your visit!"

About 45 seconds later, Text 2: "Is it okay if I give you a quick call in 15 minutes?"

Then call, whether they reply or not.

Step 3: Make the call

Keep it short, friendly, and about them. A few things to cover:

  • Introduce yourself and let them know you'll be looking for them on Sunday.
  • Ask if they have kids, and share where the kids go and how check-in works.
  • Answer the practical questions before they have to ask: where to park, which door to use, what to wear, how long the service is.
  • Share a few highlights your guests love.
  • Ask: "Is anyone else coming with you?"
  • If your church has a gift for first-time guests, mention it. Something with their name on it, waiting at the welcome center, builds excitement.
  • Ask how you can pray for them this week.

Listen for barriers, too. One church found out a guest couldn't come because she didn't have a ride. They asked if a church member could pick her up, and she gladly said yes.

Step 4: No answer? Use the two-call voicemail

Most first calls go to voicemail, and that's normal. Use this one-two punch:

  1. Call 1: leave a specific voicemail. Say who you are, why you're calling, how a quick conversation helps them, and that you'll call back in 5 minutes.
  2. Call 2: call back 5 minutes later. Now they know who's calling and why, so they're much more likely to pick up.

Voicemail script:

"Hey [First Name], this is [Your Name] from [Church Name]! I saw you planned your visit, and I wanted to introduce myself so you'll have a friendly face when you get here. I'd love to answer any questions, like where to park, what to wear, or where your kids will go. I'm going to try you again in about five minutes, and I'll send you a text from this number too. Looking forward to meeting you!"

Voicemail tips:

  • Say your name and church name in the first five seconds.
  • Smile while you talk. People can hear it.
  • Keep it under 30 seconds.
  • Don't ask them to call you back. Tell them you'll try again, then do it.

Step 5: Still no answer? Send a text that ends in a question

A text that ends with a statement ends the conversation. A text that ends with a question starts one. Keep it simple and low-pressure:

  • "Hey [First Name], it's [Your Name] from [Church Name] again. So glad you want to visit! Do you have any questions about parking or kids for Sunday?"
  • "How many people are coming with you Sunday?"
  • "Hey [First Name], it's [Your Name], [Your Title] at [Church Name]! Random offer: I'd love to have your coffee order waiting for you when you walk in. My treat. What are you drinking?" If they reply, confirm which service they plan to attend and have it ready with their name on it.

Lots of guests would rather text than talk, and that's okay. A great text conversation still builds a real connection.

Step 6: Text them the night before

Saturday night, guests are asking themselves, "Am I really doing this tomorrow?" One short text with their name in it answers that:

"Hey [First Name], we're excited to see you tomorrow! I'll be by the front doors. Just look for me."

Bonus: put a face to the name

Record a 30-second selfie video on your phone and text it to them. Casual, unpolished, and warm is exactly right:

"Hey [First Name]! I'm [Your Name] from [Church Name]. Just wanted to put a face to the name. Let me know if there's anything I can be praying about for you or your family this week."

If video isn't your thing, a quick text asking how you can pray for them works great too. And when someone shares a prayer request, answer it personally: send a video, audio message, or text that prays for them by name, then invite them to church so you can pray for them in person.

Part 2: After their first visit

Step 7: Text within the hour

That afternoon, a guest is wondering whether any of it meant anything. A text within an hour of the service, one that only a real person could have written, answers that. Use their name, and their kids' names if you know them:

"[First Name], it was so good to meet you and [Kid's Name] today! I hope you all felt at home. Anything I can be praying about for you this week?"

Step 8: Send a Monday selfie video

Early in the week, send a 30 to 60 second selfie video to each guest who visited. Say their name, mention something from Sunday, encourage them, and invite them back. This one small step makes a big difference in how many guests come back.

Step 9: Invite them to a next step, personally

Don't jump from a first visit straight to "join a group, serve on a team, and give." That's like going from a first date straight to a proposal. Offer an easy, fun second step, like a newcomers lunch or Welcome Party, and make the invite personal:

"Hey [First Name], it's [Your Name]. We've got a Welcome Party in two weeks with free food and childcare. I'll be there, and I saved you a seat!"

Make sure every guest who attends is added to your Church Fuel Visitor Follow-Up System so the relationship keeps growing after their first Sunday.

Step 10: Keep showing up

Guests who get about ten personal points of contact in their first few months are far more likely to still be at your church a year later. That doesn't mean ten sales pitches. It means ten moments where someone noticed them.

What if they don't show up?

A no-show isn't lost. It's the start of a new conversation. Your Church Fuel Visitor System keeps inviting them with an email on Thursday and a text on Saturday. For an extra personal touch, use the Church Fuel No-Show Workflow and reach out yourself early in the week, with no guilt attached:

"Hey [First Name], we missed you Sunday! Hope everything's okay. Anything I can be praying about? We'd love to see you whenever you're ready."

Then play the long game. You're reaching people who may not have a habit of going to church. Every name is a soul that matters to God, so think in years, not weeks. Remember the prodigal son and how his father patiently waited for him to come home. Some people will visit in the first month, many at the next big event, and others next Easter or Christmas. Keep getting to know them, keep inviting them, and let the 90-day nurture automation and the monthly Communication Invites and Event Invites from Church Fuel help you stay in touch throughout the year.

Quick reference: call or text?

  • Within 15 minutes of a sign-up: text first, then call.
  • No answer: voicemail, call back in 5 minutes, then a text that ends in a question.
  • They prefer texting: keep texting. A good text conversation still counts.
  • Saturday night: a short "we're excited to see you" text.
  • Within an hour after their visit: a personal text from the person who met them.
  • Early the next week: a selfie video and a personal invite to a next step.

Using Church Fuel to help

Use your Church Fuel tools to support human connection, not replace it. Church Fuel handles the busywork so your people can handle the relationships.

  • Automatic messages: your Plan Your Visit system sends the confirmation text and email, reminders, and a team alert with the guest's info and a suggested phone script. Read those messages so your personal texts line up with them.
  • The hybrid approach: let the automated system handle standard reminders and confirmations, and have a real person handle the back-and-forth conversation. For example, your first automated text could say: "Hey {{contact.first_name}}, thanks for your interest in [Church Name]. [Pastor or Host Name] will send you a personal text here soon. You can also reply with any questions or prayer requests."
  • Call and text from your church's number: download the Church Fuel app on iPhone, or the LeadConnector app on Android, and log in with your regular Church Fuel login. Calls and texts go out from your church's Church Fuel number, not your personal cell. Here's how to install it.
  • Know the moment a guest replies: go to Settings > Users, click Edit on your user, make sure your cell number is in your profile, then open Notification Settings > Conversation Notifications and check them all. You'll get a text alert when a guest replies, and you can answer from Conversations in the mobile app.
  • Track every guest: use your Connections Pipeline to move each guest through stages like Interested (form submitted), Reached Out (voicemails left or text sent), Active Conversation, Confirmed Visit, Attended, and No-Show (follow-up needed), so nobody slips through the cracks.
  • Turn your ads into prayer conversations: ask the Church Fuel Facebook Ads team to turn on Messenger for your ad campaign. This starts a Messenger conversation with new leads who respond to your ad. Ask a simple question like, "How can I be praying for you this week?" When they respond, send an audio prayer praying for them by name, and end with: "Hey, we're having church this Sunday. Can you come so we can pray for you in person?"

Related articles

Related questions

  • Why are people signing up online for church but not showing up?
  • Is it better to call or text a first-time church guest?
  • What should I say in a voicemail to a church visitor?
  • How fast should we follow up with someone who planned a visit?
  • What should I do when a Plan Your Visit sign-up ghosts me?
  • How do I follow up with someone who planned a visit but didn't show up?
  • How do I track church visitors from their first click to Sunday morning?

Need extra help?

If you'd like help setting up notifications, the mobile app, or your Connections Pipeline, our team is here for you! Reach out at churchfuel.com/support or join a live support call Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday at noon CT / 1 PM ET.

Did this answer your question? Thanks for the feedback There was a problem submitting your feedback. Please try again later.